Response to reviewers
IdeaOne row per point. Every row ends in either a change with a location, or a reasoned refusal. “We thank the reviewer” is not a response.
Round 1
| # | Reviewer | Point | Response | Change made | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Not set |
Points declined
Declining a reviewer point is legitimate and sometimes correct. It requires a reason the meta-reviewer can evaluate.
| # | Point | Why declined |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Not set |
Changes made without being asked
Recorded so the reviewer can find them.
| Change | Location |
|---|---|
| Not set |
Last updated on